In a surprising twist, the MLB’s attempt to capitalize on the pop culture phenomenon that is Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce has backfired, leaving the league scrambling. After the couple made a high-profile appearance at Game 1 of the American League Championship Series in New York City, the MLB’s social media team went all out, flooding fans with TikTok clips of the duo and playful posts speculating about their future. But what the MLB thought would be a home run turned out to be a foul ball, as the spectacle has cost them 1.5 million subscribers and a whopping $10 million in brand deals.

When Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce were spotted at Yankee Stadium on October 14, many expected their appearance to generate buzz. After all, the world has been obsessed with their budding romance. The MLB, sensing an opportunity, leaned hard into the social media frenzy, sharing posts that celebrated the duo as if they were baseball’s new power couple. One now-infamous TikTok post read, “TAYLOR SWIFT ATTENDS GAME WITH HER POTENTIAL FUTURE HUSBAND,” with the caption, “YOU TWO MAKE ME BELIEVE IN LOVE. I CAN’T STOP CRYING. NEVER CHANGE. ILYSM.”

But rather than rallying fans, the over-the-top displays of affection for Swift and Kelce turned off the MLB’s core audience. Fans, who had tuned in for playoff baseball, found themselves bombarded with celebrity gossip rather than game highlights. As one frustrated fan put it on Twitter, “I came to watch a ball game, not an episode of The Bachelorette.”

The backlash was swift and fierce. While Swifties and sports fans overlap on occasion, it turns out that MLB’s core viewership has no interest in being inundated with celebrity content. The hashtag #StickToBaseball began trending almost immediately after the MLB’s gushy social media posts, and fans let their voices be heard loud and clear.

“It’s like the MLB forgot who its audience is,” one disgruntled fan tweeted. “Taylor Swift’s great, but this is playoff season, not a pop concert.”

Others were more blunt. “Keep Taylor Swift out of baseball. We’re here for the game, not her latest love story,” another user wrote.

The sentiment was echoed across the MLB’s social media platforms, and what began as a lighthearted attempt to bridge two entertainment worlds quickly devolved into a PR crisis. By the end of the week, the MLB had lost a staggering 1.5 million subscribers, and a number of high-profile sponsors were reportedly cutting ties with the league.

The backlash didn’t just hurt the MLB’s subscriber numbers. It also hit the league where it hurts the most: in the wallet. Multiple brand partners have quietly distanced themselves from the league, with one major sponsor reportedly pulling out of a $5 million deal after the fiasco.

“We partnered with the MLB to reach sports fans, not to be part of a celebrity circus,” said a representative from one of the brands. “The league has lost focus, and we need to reconsider our partnership.”

It seems the MLB’s strategy to draw in a wider, younger audience by leaning into pop culture did not resonate with advertisers who were looking to appeal to traditional sports fans. And while Swift may be able to sell out stadiums for her concerts, she’s proving to be a tough sell when it comes to converting baseball fans.The MLB’s attempt to merge sports with pop culture could have been a clever move if executed correctly, but it’s clear that they missed the mark this time. By focusing too much on Swift and Kelce’s love story, they inadvertently alienated their primary audience — die-hard baseball fans who were tuning in to watch their teams fight for a spot in the World Series, not to hear about Taylor Swift’s potential new beau.

“MLB trying to cash in on Taylor Swift’s popularity was always going to be risky, but they didn’t expect it to blow up like this,” said sports marketing expert Kevin Harris. “They overestimated how much crossover appeal there was between their fanbases. Baseball is a traditional sport with a passionate following, and when you mess with that, you’re going to face backlash.”

The move is particularly embarrassing for the MLB, which has been trying to modernize its image and attract younger fans for years. But while Swifties might flood streaming services to catch a glimpse of their idol at a concert, they’re not flocking to MLB broadcasts in the same way.

So, what happens next? Sources say the MLB is in damage control mode, attempting to patch things up with disgruntled fans and reassure sponsors that they haven’t lost sight of their core product. Insiders say there have been internal discussions about how to better handle celebrity endorsements moving forward, though the league has yet to issue an official statement.

In the meantime, the MLB has reportedly asked its social media team to dial down the celebrity content. But it might be too little, too late. The damage has been done, and the league will have to work hard to win back the fans who have checked out.

“MLB tried to be clever by riding on Taylor Swift’s coattails, but they underestimated how seriously baseball fans take their sport,” Harris added. “They don’t want to feel like they’re being marketed to, especially not by pop stars. It’s going to be tough to rebuild that trust.”

Interestingly enough, the entire saga doesn’t seem to have affected the stars at the center of it. Swift and Kelce have continued to make public appearances together, seemingly unfazed by the controversy. For them, it was just another date night at a baseball game. But for the MLB, it was a costly misstep that they’re now scrambling to recover from.

Fans are already speculating whether the league will try something similar again in the future, or if this disaster has taught them to stick to what they do best. One thing is for sure: the MLB has a long way to go if it wants to repair its relationship with its fans and convince them that baseball, not celebrity drama, is still at the heart of the game.

The MLB’s attempt to cash in on Taylor Swift’s popularity seemed like a fun idea, but it’s backfired in spectacular fashion. While it may have briefly brought the league into the pop culture spotlight, it also cost them 1.5 million subscribers and millions in brand deals. Now, the league faces the difficult task of winning back its fans’ trust and convincing advertisers that it still knows how to appeal to its core audience.

Maybe next time, they’ll think twice before mixing baseball with celebrity. Because if there’s one thing this debacle has proven, it’s that baseball fans just want to watch a game — not a love story.