February is fast approaching, and it looks like Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift are getting ready to experience their first Valentine’s Day together as a couple, which apparently has the football player feeling somewhat uneasy.

During an ad spot released in the middle of the latest episode of his New Heights podcast, Travis and brother Jason Kelce briefly opened up about Valentine’s Day and how they usually make the day extra special. “With both of us playing in the NFL for so many years, we’ve learned a thing or two about competition, but when it comes to finding the perfect game-winning gift for Valentine’s Day, Etsy is the real MVP,” Travis reads from the ad before the conversation gets a bit more earnest.

While Jason claims he’s already on the lookout for “something extra special” for his wife Kylie Kelce, he soon backtracks. “That’s kind of a lie. I usually do it last second, just like every other man out here on the planet.” After learning that Jason gets Kylie the same chocolates, the same flowers, and a card (which at least is new) every year, Travis can’t help but semi-jokingly mock his brother.

While he doesn’t reveal his own plans for V-Day, it sure looks like he’s planning something more than a card and some chocolates for one of the biggest popstars on earth. At the end of the commercial, he admits: “Whether you’re feeling the Valentine’s Day pressure like Jason and I, or trying to figure out the right gift for a significant other, Etsy is the go-to destination for adding that special touch.”

We have a feeling Kelce won’t be giving Swift a gift from Etsy, but we are ready to be surprised. With the NFL season officially wrapping on February 11 and Swift taking a five-day break in-between Eras World Tour stops at the time, it sure looks like the couple could be cooking something up — maybe even literally. Romantic dinner, anyone?